Employment Rights Bill Report Stage: Amendment 297

Wednesday, 12 March 2025 · Division No. 121 · Commons

167Ayes
328Noes
Defeated

151 MPs did not vote

rightGovernment defeatedPro Trade Union Rights(No)Fiscal Responsibility(Yes)Public Sector Productivity(Yes)Pro Workers Rights(No)

Voting Yes means

Support requiring public sector employers to secure productivity commitments from trade unions in return for pay increases, ensuring taxpayers get value from union deals

Voting No means

Oppose attaching such conditions, backing the Employment Rights Bill as drafted without additional constraints on public sector union negotiations

What happened: The House of Commons voted on Amendment 297 to the Employment Rights Bill during its Report Stage on 12 March 2025. The amendment, tabled by the Conservatives, was defeated by 328 votes to 167. The amendment related to trade union industrial action and sought to place additional conditions or restrictions on how trade unions could organise and carry out industrial action.

Why it matters: The Employment Rights Bill is one of the most significant pieces of employment legislation in a generation, covering areas from zero-hours contracts and statutory sick pay to trade union rights and enforcement powers. Amendment 297 focused specifically on the industrial relations provisions of the Bill, seeking to modify the framework governing trade union activity. Its defeat means the government's original approach to these provisions remains intact, preserving the expanded rights and protections for trade unions that the Bill contains. The vote affects millions of workers who are trade union members, as well as employers across both public and private sectors who will need to operate within the reformed industrial relations framework.

The politics: The vote divided almost entirely along party lines. All 279 Labour MPs and 27 Labour and Co-operative MPs who voted opposed the amendment, while all 94 voting Conservatives and 62 voting Liberal Democrats supported it. Reform UK's five voting MPs also backed the amendment, as did three Democratic Unionists and four independents. The SNP, Plaid Cymru, and the Greens all voted against. The debate was marked by sharp exchanges over trade union funding of the Labour Party, with Conservative MPs arguing the Bill represented political payback for union financial support, and Labour MPs defending trade union members as ordinary working people whose rights deserved protection.

How They Voted

Government position: No

Labour PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/279 No
Conservative and Unionist PartyWhipped Aye
94 Aye/0 No
Liberal DemocratsWhipped Aye
62 Aye/0 No
Labour and Co-operative PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/27 No
Scottish National PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/9 No
Independent
4 Aye/4 No
Reform UKWhipped Aye
5 Aye/0 No
Green Party of England and WalesWhipped No
0 Aye/4 No
Plaid CymruWhipped No
0 Aye/4 No
Democratic Unionist PartyWhipped Aye
3 Aye/0 No
Social Democratic and Labour Party
0 Aye/1 No
Ulster Unionist Party
1 Aye/0 No
Your Party
0 Aye/1 No

What They Said in the Debate

Greg Smith

Conservative · Mid Buckinghamshire

Opposed

Opposes the Bill as economically damaging, claims it increases regulatory burden on businesses, contests union political fund opt-out changes, and argues the 14-day strike notice period should be retained

Voted Aye

Wendy Morton

Conservative · Aldridge-Brownhills

Opposed

Criticises Government's understanding of small business definitions and argues the Bill's balance is fundamentally wrong for SMEs

Sir Julian Lewis

Conservative · New Forest East

Questioning

Questions whether Government mechanisms will make opt-out processes for union political funds transparent and easy for members

Voted Aye

Sarah Russell

Independent/Liberal · Congleton

Questioning

Questions Opposition claim about political fund ballots by noting they have historically never resulted in fund closures

Voted No

Justin Madders

Labour · Ellesmere Port and Bromborough

Supportive

Supports Government amendments modernising industrial relations framework, strengthening union access, simplifying strike ballots, and empowering the Fair Work Agency to enforce employment rights

Voted No

Liam Byrne

Labour · Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North

Supportive

Welcomes enforcement improvements but questions whether Modern Slavery Act reform will be addressed alongside Fair Work Agency measures

Voted No

Gareth Snell

Labour · Stoke-on-Trent Central

Supportive

Defends trade union contributions to Labour MPs and challenges Conservatives on undisclosed business interests

Voted No

Related Votes