Employment Rights Bill Report Stage: New Clause 39

Wednesday, 12 March 2025 · Division No. 118 · Commons

337Ayes
98Noes
Passed

209 MPs did not vote

leftGovernment wonPro Workers Rights(Yes)Pro Trade Union Rights(Yes)Pro Employment Regulation(Yes)Anti Business Regulation(No)

Voting Yes means

Support the government's package of amendments to strengthen and clarify workers' rights, including protections for agency workers, improved redundancy consultation rules, and establishing a Social Care Negotiating Body.

Voting No means

Oppose these government amendments, likely on grounds that they impose excessive burdens on businesses or expand state intervention in employment relations too far.

Parliament voted on 12 March 2025 to pass New Clause 39 of the Employment Rights Bill at Report Stage, by 337 votes to 98. The clause was part of a package of government amendments covering parts 4 and 5 of the Bill, dealing with trade union law and employment enforcement. The government won decisively, with the result reflecting its substantial Commons majority.

New Clause 39 formed part of a broader set of government amendments described by ministers as modernising the industrial relations framework. The wider package included changes to industrial action ballot thresholds, notice requirements for employers ahead of ballots, the period for which a ballot result remains effective, and the enforcement powers of the newly created Fair Work Agency. The amendments also extended the Fair Work Agency's remit to cover statutory sick pay and holiday pay enforcement, and brought Northern Ireland statutory sick pay legislation into scope, subject to consent from the Northern Ireland Executive. Ministers framed these as practical improvements designed to make the Bill work better for workers and businesses.

Party divisions were clear and consistent with the bill's broader passage. Labour and Labour and Co-operative members voted unanimously in favour, alongside the Scottish National Party, Plaid Cymru, the Greens, the Social Democratic and Labour Party, the Democratic Unionist Party, and a majority of independents. All 95 Conservative members who voted opposed the clause, joined by all six Reform UK members who voted, and one independent. There were no notable cross-party rebellions in either direction.

How They Voted

Government position: Aye

Labour PartyWhipped Aye
280 Aye/0 No
Conservative and Unionist PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/95 No
Labour and Co-operative PartyWhipped Aye
29 Aye/0 No
Scottish National PartyWhipped Aye
9 Aye/0 No
Independent
7 Aye/1 No
Reform UKWhipped No
0 Aye/6 No
Plaid CymruWhipped Aye
4 Aye/0 No
Green Party of England and WalesWhipped Aye
3 Aye/0 No
Democratic Unionist Party
2 Aye/0 No
Social Democratic and Labour Party
2 Aye/0 No
Ulster Unionist Party
1 Aye/0 No
Your Party
1 Aye/0 No

What They Said in the Debate

Greg Smith

Conservative · Mid Buckinghamshire

Opposed

Opposes the Bill as economically damaging, claims it increases regulatory burden on businesses, contests union political fund opt-out changes, and argues the 14-day strike notice period should be retained

Voted No

Wendy Morton

Conservative · Aldridge-Brownhills

Opposed

Criticises Government's understanding of small business definitions and argues the Bill's balance is fundamentally wrong for SMEs

Sir Julian Lewis

Conservative · New Forest East

Questioning

Questions whether Government mechanisms will make opt-out processes for union political funds transparent and easy for members

Voted No

Sarah Russell

Independent/Liberal · Congleton

Questioning

Questions Opposition claim about political fund ballots by noting they have historically never resulted in fund closures

Voted Aye

Justin Madders

Labour · Ellesmere Port and Bromborough

Supportive

Supports Government amendments modernising industrial relations framework, strengthening union access, simplifying strike ballots, and empowering the Fair Work Agency to enforce employment rights

Voted Aye

Liam Byrne

Labour · Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North

Supportive

Welcomes enforcement improvements but questions whether Modern Slavery Act reform will be addressed alongside Fair Work Agency measures

Voted Aye

Gareth Snell

Labour · Stoke-on-Trent Central

Supportive

Defends trade union contributions to Labour MPs and challenges Conservatives on undisclosed business interests

Voted Aye

Related Votes

Employment Rights Bill Report Stage: New Clause 39 — Wednesday, 12 March 2025 | Beyond The Vote