Finance Bill Report Stage: Amendment 67
Monday, 3 March 2025 · Division No. 111 · Commons
136 MPs did not vote
Voting Yes means
Support requiring a formal review of how the higher windfall tax on oil and gas profits affects UK energy production, security, prices, and the economy
Voting No means
Oppose mandating a separate impact assessment, arguing the government has already assessed the policy and the levy increase should proceed without delay
Parliament voted on Amendment 67 to the Finance Bill at Report Stage on 3 March 2025. The amendment was tabled by Conservative MPs and sought to remove or modify specific tax increases contained in the Bill. The government defeated the amendment by 347 votes to 167, a majority of 180.
The Finance Bill gives legal effect to the measures announced in Chancellor Rachel Reeves's October 2024 Budget, described by the government as a growth Budget. The amendment targeted a range of tax changes that opponents argued would damage the economy, reduce business investment and harm household finances. These included the increase in employers' national insurance contributions, the extension and rate increase of the energy profits levy on North sea oil and gas producers, the removal of the VAT exemption for independent schools, and changes to inheritance tax and business property relief. Defeating the amendment means all these measures remain on course to become law.
The vote divided almost entirely along party lines. All 291 Labour MPs and 37 Labour and Co-operative MPs who voted did so against the amendment, as did all seven SNP members, all four Plaid Cymru members and all four Green MPs. On the other side, all 94 voting Conservatives, all 59 voting Liberal Democrats, all six voting Reform UK members and three Democratic Unionist Party members supported the amendment. Three independents voted for it and two against. The Liberal Democrats, despite voting with the Conservatives here, expressed their own distinct objections, particularly on private school VAT and small business impacts, rather than fully endorsing the Conservative position. There were no notable Labour rebels.
How They Voted
Government position: No
What They Said in the Debate
Conservative · North West Norfolk
Opposes Finance Bill measures including state pension tax, energy profits levy hike, and VAT on independent schools; seeks impact reviews to expose harm to pensioners, businesses, and energy security.
Voted Aye
Conservative · Bridgwater
Condemns Bill as breaking manifesto promises, punishing businesses through NI hikes, attacking farmers with inheritance tax, and stifling growth; calls for impact assessments of damage.
Voted Aye
Liberal Democrat · Wimbledon
Opposes VAT on private schools; warns of adverse impacts on SEND pupils and wine industry; criticises impractical alcohol duty regime creating 30 different duty rates for wine.
Voted Aye
DUP · Strangford
Supports new clauses 2, 7, 8 as impact assessments; warns of VAT harm to faith schools and distilleries in Northern Ireland; opposes NI contributions rise.
Voted Aye
Liberal Democrat · St Albans
Seeks impact assessments on SMEs, households, alcohol duty impacts on distilleries/wine trade, and SEND pupils without EHCPs; opposes VAT on private schools but requests evidence of harm.
Voted Aye
Labour · Loughborough
Supports Finance Bill as necessary to ensure economic growth benefits are shared fairly across all income levels, demographics, and regions; backs investments in skills, housing, and childcare.
Voted No
Labour · Dartford
Defends Finance Bill as fixing an unfair tax system inherited from 14 years of Conservative government; argues most requested data already published; dismisses new clauses as duplicate work.
Voted No
Labour · Barking
Supports Bill's non-dom changes, energy profits levy, and VAT on private schools as fair taxation choices; backs long-term stability in energy markets alongside immediate price relief.
Voted No
Related Votes
Opposition Day: Business and the economy
21 May 2025
Bank Resolution (Recapitalisation) Bill [Lords]: New Clause 3
24 Apr 2025
Bank Resolution (Recapitalisation) Bill [Lords]: Amendment 2
24 Apr 2025
Non-Domestic Rating (Multipliers and Private Schools) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 1B
31 Mar 2025
Non-Domestic Rating (Multipliers and Private Schools) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 2B
31 Mar 2025
Non-Domestic Rating (Multipliers and Private Schools) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 13B
31 Mar 2025
Non-Domestic Rating (Multipliers and Private Schools) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendments 15B, 15C, 15D, 15E
31 Mar 2025
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 1B
25 Mar 2025
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 5B
25 Mar 2025
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill: Motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 8B
25 Mar 2025