Great British Energy Bill Report Stage: Amendment 6

Tuesday, 29 October 2024 · Division No. 25 · Commons

124Ayes
361Noes
Defeated

164 MPs did not vote

rightGovernment defeatedEnergy Cost Transparency(Yes)Pro Clean Energy Transition(No)Anti Net Zero Costs(Yes)Fiscal Responsibility(Yes)

Voting Yes means

Support requiring GB Energy to publish clear, year-by-year cost estimates for the energy transition so that MPs and the public can scrutinise what decarbonisation will actually cost households

Voting No means

Oppose the amendment, arguing it could be used to undermine the clean energy transition and that cost transparency requirements of this kind are not appropriate in the Bill

Parliament voted on Amendment 6 to the Great British Energy Bill during its Report Stage on 29 October 2024. The amendment, put forward by the Conservatives, sought to limit or modify the scope of Great British Energy, the proposed publicly owned clean energy company. The vote was defeated by 361 votes to 124, meaning the amendment did not pass and the Bill continued without the proposed changes.

The Great British Energy Bill is the Government's flagship legislation to create a state-owned energy company intended to accelerate investment in renewable energy, reduce reliance on fossil fuels, and support communities and local energy projects. Defeating this amendment means the Bill will proceed in its current form, without the restrictions the Conservatives sought to impose. The legislation affects energy policy across the whole of the United Kingdom, with implications for energy bills, the green energy transition, jobs, and community-level power generation.

The vote divided almost entirely along party lines. All 316 Labour MPs and all 36 Labour and Co-operative MPs voted against the amendment, alongside the three Green MPs. The 99 Conservative MPs present voted in favour, joined by all nine Scottish National Party members, all six Reform UK members, all five Democratic Unionist Party members, and one Ulster Unionist. Five independents voted on each side. There were no notable cross-party rebellions. The debate took place one day before the 2024 Autumn Budget, with the Conservatives using the occasion to criticise broader Labour economic decisions, while Labour MPs defended the Bill as essential to cleaning up what they described as the previous government's energy failures.

How They Voted

Government position: No

Labour PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/316 No
Conservative and Unionist PartyWhipped Aye
99 Aye/0 No
Labour and Co-operative PartyWhipped No
0 Aye/36 No
Independent
5 Aye/5 No
Scottish National PartyWhipped Aye
9 Aye/0 No
Reform UKWhipped Aye
6 Aye/0 No
Democratic Unionist PartyWhipped Aye
5 Aye/0 No
Green Party of England and WalesWhipped No
0 Aye/3 No
Ulster Unionist Party
1 Aye/0 No
Your Party
0 Aye/1 No

What They Said in the Debate

Claire Coutinho

Conservative · East Surrey

Opposed

Opposition shadow minister demanding amendments to hold government accountable for unfulfilled election promises on £300 bill cuts and 650,000 jobs; also tabled independent review requirement for GB Energy oversight.

Voted Aye

Dr Kieran Mullan

Conservative · Bexhill and Battle

Questioning

Called for GB Energy to prioritise deep geothermal technology as strategic priority for heat decarbonisation and economic transition of oil/gas workforce.

Voted Aye

Pippa Heylings

Liberal Democrat · South Cambridgeshire

Neutral

Supported Bill in principle but pressed for amendments ensuring community energy and home insulation are explicit duties; expressed concern government words differ from legislative commitments.

Luke Murphy

Labour · Basingstoke

Supportive

Defended government as cleaning up 14 years of Conservative energy mismanagement and reliance on volatile fossil fuels.

Voted No

Natalie Fleet

Labour · Bolsover

Supportive

Made maiden speech endorsing Great British Energy Bill as transformative for communities like Bolsover, delivering jobs, cheaper energy, and state investment in left-behind areas.

Voted No

Torcuil Crichton

Labour · Na h-Eileanan an Iar

Supportive

Championed Bill's potential for community energy investment and local wealth distribution; argued infrastructure success depends on local community buy-in and benefit-sharing.

Voted No

Adam Thompson

Labour · Erewash

Supportive

Made maiden speech supporting Bill as delivering energy security and jobs for manufacturing-based constituencies like Erewash, replacing fossil fuel reliance.

Voted No

Siân Berry

Green · Brighton Pavilion

Supportive

Backed new clauses requiring nature recovery duty and prohibition on investments increasing greenhouse gas emissions to strengthen environmental outcomes.

Voted No

Related Votes