Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 2

On 27 January 2026, the House of Commons voted on Amendment 2 to the Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill at committee stage. The amendment was defeated by 311 votes to 61. The amendment was tabled by the Liberal Democrats and related to concerns about ministerial powers under the Bill -- specifically the use of the "negative procedure" (a parliamentary process that allows secondary legislation to pass without a full debate or vote unless MPs object) to change who qualifies for prioritisation in medical training. The Liberal Democrats, Plaid Cymru, the Green Party, and a handful of independents voted in favour; Labour, Labour and Co-operative, the DUP, and Ulster Unionist Party voted against. The Conservatives were entirely absent from this division. The Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill aims to give priority to graduates of UK and Irish medical schools when allocating foundation and specialty training places in the NHS. Amendment 2 sought to require that any future changes to who qualifies for prioritisation be subject to greater parliamentary oversight, rather than being made by the Secretary of State alone through the negative procedure. In practical terms, the amendment's defeat means that the Government retains the power to redefine the eligibility criteria for prioritisation without Parliament needing to vote on those changes. Critics argued this could allow Ministers to quietly redraw access to NHS training posts without meaningful democratic scrutiny -- a significant matter given that training places are a gateway to NHS careers for thousands of doctors. The vote split broadly along government versus opposition lines, though with notable asymmetry. Labour and its Co-operative partners voted unanimously against the amendment, reflecting the Government's position that ministerial flexibility was necessary. The Liberal Democrats, who have expressed general support for the Bill's objectives, nonetheless voted as a bloc in favour -- arguing that accountability and transparency warranted stronger parliamentary controls. Plaid Cymru and the Greens also backed the amendment. The Conservatives, despite having tabled their own amendments to the Bill on the same day, were entirely absent from this particular division -- a striking gap given the party's size. The vote sits within a broader debate about the appropriate balance between executive discretion and parliamentary scrutiny in NHS workforce policy, a theme that has run through several amendments to this Bill.