Speeches by Shastri-Hurst.

“I do not think that offends the principle at all. Whether I was working within the NHS or the private sector, if a patient requested an onward referral to a different specialist, I would action that. If I did not have the requisite skills or knowledge, or felt that they would be better served by a different speciality,…”

“Will the hon. Lady give way?”

“My hon. Friend is making a valid argument, but I want to pick up the point made by the hon. Member for Stroud. He talked about illnesses that are inevitably progressive and cannot be reversed by treatment. For type 1 diabetes—I think that is what my hon. Friend the Member for South Northamptonshire (Sarah Bool) is addr…”

“I will try to make some progress. I want to move on to the other point I want to address, which is around bogging down the whole process with layer upon layer of bureaucracy. We are talking about a relatively small group of patients who are in the last six months of life and are then battling against the system that is…”

“Forgive me, Chair. I will come to the point. If the person does not have insulin, the diabetes could be treated by administering it. Does my hon. Friend accept that, in those circumstances, it would fall within this clause?”

“I fear that my hon. Friend may be oversimplifying what I was saying. Perhaps I was not clear enough, so I will elucidate. I was certainly not suggesting that the required skills were merely those of being able to have a consultation and a conversation. I was talking about having the skills to have the information that …”

“I am grateful to you, Chair, and to my hon. Friend the Member for Reigate for her intervention. She is right: it is absolutely critical that patients are given the full information in order to make an informed choice. I do not think any of us would disagree with that. But actually that goes entirely with the wording of…”

“It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I start by gently pushing back on what my hon. Friend the Member for East Wiltshire said about this being a fork in the road. I do not see the Bill giving patients that ultimate option. They have the choice to opt for an assisted death while continuing with …”

“Go on—I am feeling generous.”

“I will give way because the hon. Lady has been very patient.”

“I am grateful to the hon. Lady for her intervention. She makes a number of points. First, may I say that I am sorry about her own health issues? I think she hit the nail on the head when she said that the GP may not be able to offer that service. For instance, take shoulder injections. Some GPs can do a shoulder inject…”

“I am feeling generous—it is a Tuesday.”

“The hon. Member makes a valid point. The reality is that, regardless of specialty title, there will be individuals who are better placed to have certain conversations and discuss certain issues than others. I look back at my own clinical practice: some colleagues would have had a better bedside manner than others, for …”

“I am grateful for the hon. Member’s intervention, which leads on to the point I was going to make. We are getting bogged down in nomenclature about what speciality is involved when this is actually about training. It is about whether the individual having the conversation has the requisite skills to have a meaningful c…”

“It is a sad reality of life that marriages fail. It can happen for a variety of reasons, and I do not seek to provide a critique on the underlying causes in today’s debate. However, one of the tragic consequences of divorce is the disruption and pain that it causes to children. It is evident that an amicable relationsh…”

“I just want to understand this, so that I can appreciate the amendment in full. I believe that my hon. Friend—he will correct me if I misheard—spoke of encouragement effectively being pressure: that there is the act of encouragement and then an individual being pressured into making a decision that is not in their best…”

“It may be that I am a dense former surgeon, so please help me, but could my hon. Friend the Member for East Wiltshire give an example of what, in the definition of “encouragement”, would be broader than “pressure”? If we are not saying that supporting somebody through this process is acceptable, what would be a specifi…”

“The hon. Lady spoke movingly about her own experiences, which clearly fell into the category of benefiting others, with no benefit for herself. Can she elucidate how she envisages this amendment working in the following scenario? Let us say that in some years to come, this law is enacted and I have a terminal illness—I…”

“My hon. Friend makes a powerful argument, but if that is his intention, the amendment does not achieve it. It does not refer to agonising pain; it just refers to “physical pain”. On a scale of nought to 10, it could be one or two—it does not necessarily mean that it is nine or 10. While his intention is clear, can he e…”

“I have no doubt that my hon. Friend speaks to the amendment with very good intentions due to genuine concerns about the safeguards. We have talked a lot about coercion. Clause 1(2)(b) sets out a requirement that the person, “has made the decision that they wish to end their own life voluntarily and has not been coerced…”