Speeches by Garnier.

“Q It is happening; that is very good, and it is good to hear that there is a pipeline being developed. It is certainly something that has been talked about for a number of years. When I was the investment Minister back in 2017-18, we were very keen to get foreign direct investment coming in to the UK, so there was the …”

“Q It has been suggested to me that the mere fact that this reserve power is in existence may subconsciously encourage funds to invest in the UK, and that therefore they can naturally find 5% investment into the UK and infrastructure, or maybe even more. Do you think that is a valid point? Sophia Singleton: What I would…”

“Q So if this clause is passed, we could potentially see a drop-off in the performance of pension funds? Helen Forrest Hall: I am not sure that we would draw a direct correlation, but the point is that it will start to influence investment decisions. Those may be good decisions, or not, and they may be decisions that tr…”

“Q Helen, can I pick up on your comment that you have to make long-term decisions? These reserve powers have a sunset clause that will apply in 2035. Presumably, if you are making an investment decision, you have to take that into account. An investment decision could be expected to pay out in 2040, and in making that d…”

“Q I have one final question, if I may. You run a pool of 11 funds. This is taking 87 into six. Everybody seems to think that is a good idea. Are you included in the “everybody”? Rachel Elwell: I do think there is a fantastic opportunity for us to harness the benefits of scale that come from being one of the top 10 glob…”

“Q There has been a lot of talk about mandation, which you will be well aware of. Over the time that I have been researching it, over the last few months, we have had pretty much exclusively commentary that it is not a very good thing. Tell me that that is wrong. Why is it possibly a good thing? Helen Forrest Hall: I wo…”

“Q Would you support that? Robert McInroy: I support looking at the range of options, which includes reducing employer contributions and flexing investment strategy, including for some of the areas that we have talked about and will be talking about, that could be available to the LGPS in terms of investments.”

“Q Would you suggest a higher hurdle for valuations in terms of surplus distribution? Robert McInroy: That has been discussed on a fund-by-fund basis—whether the funding target should be increased from something like 100% to 120%, for example. That has been actively discussed.”

“Q That is very helpful. Robert, would you like to add anything? Robert McInroy: Yes, on the last point about surpluses. I am a fund actuary. We are working through the 2025 valuations, and it is pleasing to see improvements in funding levels across the LGPS. We think that that, in turn, can mean lower contribution rate…”

“Q There is potential for surpluses to be paid back into the community. Is that not a good alternative for that type of more social investment as opposed to non-commercial investments? Councillor Phillips: We anticipate that the latest round of valuations will show a very good surplus for all the pensions. That is credi…”

“Q So the key point is that every single investment must be done on a benefit analysis rather than a social good analysis? Councillor Phillips: If you do not do that, I do not know where you are going with your pension investment.”

“Q It is difficult. You raised the point about geographical location and that a mayoral authority could have three different funds within it. More important, Cornwall county council, for example, may suddenly discover it is having to invest into Northumbria because that is where somebody decides it needs to invest, and …”

“Thanks to our Conservative winter fuel payments campaign, thousands of pensioners have signed up to pension credit, and millions more pensioners will receive winter fuel allowance, now that the Labour party has admitted that its policy on winter fuel payments was wrong. However, the Social Security Advisory Committee r…”

“Thank goodness I was called to speak after all. I congratulate the hon. Member for Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch (Katrina Murray) on securing this debate. It has been fascinating to listen to all the great words used to describe credit unions. We have heard them described as lifeline services, community builders and fi…”

“I am very grateful to the Minister for advance sight of her statement. There is much in these Leeds reforms—many of which were formerly known as the Edinburgh reforms—that can be welcomed, and some of the details were laid out by the Chancellor in her Mansion House speech last night. The Conservatives will always suppo…”

“It is always a great pleasure to serve under you, Mr Twigg, and I apologise for nearly knocking you over on my bicycle first thing this morning.”

“The former City Minister raises a good and important point. He tries to bring together a number of related but quite disparate issues that we need to think carefully about. I would not want to make Conservative party policy on the hoof at the Dispatch Box, though the Minister urges me to do so. These are important poin…”

“It is a great pleasure to be here with you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the Minister to his place. He has been here a couple of days over a year and is already taking an important Bill through Parliament. It is good to see him, and I very much look forward to working constructively with him as the Bill progress…”

“The hon. Member makes an important point. The earlier people start putting money in, the better. As a result of compound interest, over many years they will end up with a bigger pension pot, even if at the beginning the contribution is quite small; the amount aggregates over a long period. We will discuss that in Commi…”

“It is an important question, and one that I will come to in due course. Watch this space for a fascinating manifesto in the run-up to the next general election—I am sure everybody looks forward to it.”