Speeches by Tidball.

“Q I want to follow up, because this is really important in strengthening the Bill. Based on your prosecutorial experience, what key elements should be present in the definitions of coercion, pressure and dishonesty? I also have a bit of a technical question, if I may. Do you think they would be better placed in clause …”

“Q It is extremely helpful to understand the opportunity for scrutiny before death. Building on that point, are there any safeguards around those practices that are not currently included in the Bill but should be, particularly around detecting coercion and exploring alternative care options? I also have one follow-up q…”

“That is very helpful; thank you.”

“Q You talked about the role of medical practitioners discussing this issue, which is of course in clause 4(2) of the Bill. Paragraph 4.2 in your own evidence was very helpful in discussing that, as it makes it clear that it is “entirely consistent with current medical practice and with compassionate care” to raise assi…”

“Q On the basis of your 39 years of experience and the Select Committee evidence that I mentioned earlier, do you acknowledge that improvements on both assisted dying and palliative care can run in parallel and do not need to be mutually exclusive? Dr Ahmedzai: In the interests of brevity, yes.”

“I have two follow-up questions on that basis.”

“Q My question is for Dr Ahmedzai. The Select Committee inquiry into assisted dying received evidence that there were not any indications of palliative or end-of-life care deteriorating in quality or provision following the introduction of assisted dying. Indeed, the introduction of it has been linked with an improvemen…”

“Q But you believe that your members would be able to pick up on and identify issues such as coercion? Professor Ranger: I do. They are professionals, and I believe they would be able to.”

“Q Just to follow up on that, because it is really important: do you think your members would have the ability to pick up on such coercion, dishonesty and pressure from other parties potentially being placed on a patient who is seeking assisted dying? What other training or support would be needed for your members? Prof…”

“Q To pick up on your important point about advocacy, how would your members detect coercion, undue pressure or dishonesty by family members or other supporting parties on which the patient was relying in relation to seeking assisted dying? At what point would there be a report to the police by your members? Professor R…”

“Two weeks ago, my constituency was hit by the worst snow in 15 years, leaving vulnerable and older residents, schools and GP surgeries blocked in by the snow. I commend the Barnsley council team, who were out 24 hours a day, eight days a week solid, but because resources are stretched, their gritters can cover only the…”

“I beg to move, That this House has considered the presumption of parental involvement in child arrangements. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Western. There must be urgent reform of the presumption of parental involvement in child arrangements, known in law as presumption of contact, on the basis of e…”

“I do agree, and those factors have a cumulative, additive effect on those young people, silencing their voices even more so than those of other victims. That is one of the reasons why the harm report was clear that “the presumption should not remain in its present form” and recommended that it be reviewed “urgently in …”

“I do agree, and I thank my hon. Friend for her powerful statement. That is why we must urgently spell this issue out in primary legislation, alongside having a more tightly drawn definition of domestic abuse towards children in section 3 of the 2021 Act. Over four years have passed since the UK Government launched a re…”

“I certainly agree. To illustrate why, I want hon. Members to imagine a school night with a child being repeatedly asked by his father if he had completed his homework. The child replied in an exasperated tone, “Yes.” His dad stepped towards him with his fists ready to punch him. The boy’s mum stepped into the space bet…”

“I agree, and nowhere is that clearer than in the cases of my constituent’s sons, Jack and Paul. Not only was their father known to be abusive, but the boys did not want to see him—all while he was demanding 50:50 contact in the family courts. Claire promised her sons that she would not rest until the law was changed to…”

“I do agree. Our court system should be one where justice is achieved for vulnerable victims of abuse, rather than an additional and secondary means of victimising them.”

“I absolutely do. Furthermore, in response to my hon. Friend’s important point, the report specifically stated: “To the extent that the courts’ pro-contact culture operates as a barrier to addressing domestic abuse, it serves to reinforce that culture.” Indeed, section 6 of the report laid bare that children’s voices ar…”

“Absolutely. I will return to this later, but the harm report makes quite clear the re-traumatisation of both children and parental victims of domestic abuse that comes with repeated attempts at contact and the presumption that is currently in place. The consequence of that is a generation of lost voices like Jack and P…”

“I agree. As someone who has worked in criminology and criminal justice for over a decade, I think the need for us to move beyond siloed working can be no more important than it is in these sorts of cases. Just yesterday, we learned that the man Kiena Dawes named as her killer when she committed suicide wants to launch …”