Speeches by Gardner.

“I have been working for several months to help a number of my constituents get the wheelchairs they need to have good-quality, independent lives. While I understand that it is the role of integrated care boards to deliver equality of service, the problem is much more widespread. The Wheelchair Alliance recommends that …”

“I am conscious that my former colleagues at NHS England will be concerned about today’s announcement, but I am very confident that the Secretary of State will do all he can to support them. It is an inescapable fact that the 2012 reorganisation led to inefficient layers of management in the NHS, delivering poorer care …”

“I declare that I am a proud member of Unison, and I refer the House to my entries in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests. I rise to speak in support of this groundbreaking Employment Rights Bill, which will deliver pro-business and pro-worker reforms. It will establish day one rights, such as rights to parenta…”

“It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Hyndburn (Sarah Smith) for securing this important debate. Many of my constituents in Stoke-on-Trent South care deeply about the conflict in Jammu and Kashmir and have family there, as do many British Asians of Jammu an…”

“I of course agree with my hon. Friend. I am of course aware that we are speaking during the holy month of Ramadan. This is a time of deep reflection when it is very apt that we discuss the need for peace and resolution. It is, of course, the role of India and Pakistan to seek a diplomatic and political resolution and a…”

“Can I at least ask that, in any interactions with the Indian Government, Ministers push for the prosecution of men who use rape and sexual violence as tools of oppression? They are not being prosecuted at the moment.”

“Does the Minister agree that investment in the fifty500 midlands growth corridor will provide an excellent opportunity to deliver this Labour Government’s mission for growth and opportunity for all?”

“James, I know you mentioned that you do not look at output labelling, so I might broaden this and have Sebastian’s input. I am interested in whether the soft binding and hard binding protocols that you are doing for input could be expanded to output labelling—with generative AI, understanding that something has been pr…”

“It is good that it does not need to be a binary debate. Max, as an artist currently, what do you do to work out whether bad-faith actors have used your work legitimately?”

“There are a lot of unintended consequences. I want to come to Max in a moment but, Matt, linked to some of the comments there, what would be the commercial trade-offs for AI developers if the Government were to introduce data transparency? Regardless of the approach, but in light of these unintended consequences, if we…”

“Going on to data transparency, Ed Newton-Rex has said, “What is the use of knowing your data is being used if you cannot do anything about it?” Sajeeda, is data transparency a compromise to allow for unrestricted training?”

“Yes, and it is one of the big problems that we see on social media in videos and so on. That is in a different inquiry that we are doing. Sebastian, can I go to you on the same question, but particularly about the technical aspects of what would be involved in such labelling and how it would be presented?”

“James, I know you mentioned that you do not look at output labelling, so I might broaden this and have Sebastian’s input. I am interested in whether the soft binding and hard binding protocols that you are doing for input could be expanded to output labelling—with generative AI, understanding that something has been pr…”

“That is really interesting; thank you. I want to ask about consistency, but do you want to jump in, Chair?”

“I do like the sound of a flag. I am still trying to understand how your bog standard user scrolling through on the internet and looking at images and video would know whether it was AI-generated. It is great that they see those flags in the industry, but how would it be technically presented?”

“It is good that it does not need to be a binary debate. Max, as an artist currently, what do you do to work out whether bad-faith actors have used your work legitimately?”

“There are a lot of unintended consequences. I want to come to Max in a moment but, Matt, linked to some of the comments there, what would be the commercial trade-offs for AI developers if the Government were to introduce data transparency? Regardless of the approach, but in light of these unintended consequences, if we…”

“Going on to data transparency, Ed Newton-Rex has said, “What is the use of knowing your data is being used if you cannot do anything about it?” Sajeeda, is data transparency a compromise to allow for unrestricted training?”

“That is really interesting; thank you. I want to ask about consistency, but do you want to jump in, Chair?”

“I do like the sound of a flag. I am still trying to understand how your bog standard user scrolling through on the internet and looking at images and video would know whether it was AI-generated. It is great that they see those flags in the industry, but how would it be technically presented?”